Jeff Fisher once told a room of NFL rookies about a mistake that cost his team a game.
It happened during a 2003 matchup against Washington. Fisher called a timeout, walked his left cornerback through the coverage they were about to run, and got a fast, confident answer back.
"I gotcha, coach. I gotcha, coach."
The ball was snapped. The player made the wrong read. A Washington receiver ran wide open into the end zone. The Titans lost by three points.
After the game, Titans owner Bud Adams told a reporter they got out-coached. But that framing misses what actually happened. A player heard his coach and never listened to him.
Hearing and Listening Are Not the Same Skill
That cornerback wasn't blowing off his coach. He believed he understood the assignment. He said the words back with confidence. He was still wrong.
That's what makes this dangerous for anyone leading a team. A captain who says "got it" isn't lying to you. They might fully believe they've got it. Hearing feels like understanding from the inside, right up until it doesn't hold up under pressure.
Active listening requires you to set aside your own agenda in the moment and fully concentrate on the person and the message in front of you. In a timeout, with the clock running, that's hard for a coach. It's equally hard for a player whose heart rate just spiked.
The failure in Fisher's story wasn't only a player failure. It was a systems failure. Nobody built in a check for whether the message actually crossed the gap.
Three Ways to Test for Listening Instead of Agreement
If "I got you, coach" isn't proof of anything, here's what to use instead.
Teach-back. Ask the person to explain the assignment back in their own words, not a repeat of yours. If they can only parrot your phrasing, you don't know if they understood you or just memorized you.
Chunking. Under real pressure, people can't process a four-part instruction the way they can at rest. Give one directive. Confirm it landed. Then give the next one.
A listening cue. Build a signal into your program before the season gets to a close game, a word or gesture that means "stop, repeat this back to me." You won't invent that trust mid-game. Build it in preseason so it's automatic when it matters.
Why Your Captains Don't Hear the Same Word You Do
There's a concept out of design and business research called shared language. Two people can use the exact same word and mean two different things by it, and nobody notices until something breaks. That's what happened on that Titans sideline. Fisher and his cornerback both would have said, before the snap, that they understood the coverage. They just didn't understand it the same way.
You say "lead" constantly. You say "compete" constantly. Have you ever defined those words out loud, or did you assume it was obvious?
Before the season, sit your captains down and build a shared glossary. Pick your five most-used words and have each captain tell you what they think a word means when you say it under pressure. Fix the gap in a walkthrough, not in a timeout with the game on the line.
Delivery Is Part of the Message
How you say something isn't separate from what you're saying. Most speakers spend all their preparation time on content and almost none on delivery, when the ratio should run the other way. You've given the same assignment a hundred times this season. If you deliver it flat because you're tired of saying it, your captain reads that flatness as low stakes.
Your captain is hearing that assignment for the first time, in this exact moment, even if you've said a version of it fifty times. Deliver it like the stakes match the moment.
The Story That Reframes Everything
I heard Jeff Fisher tell this part live, at the 2026 Soldiers to Sidelines Summit, and it landed harder in the room than it does on paper.
A few years into his time in Tennessee, Fisher brought a group of hearing-impaired children in to talk with his players. These kids couldn't hear a single word in that room. Everything came to them through an interpreter. And Fisher's point to his players was that those kids listened to every single thing that was said, because their lives depend on their ability to listen rather than just hear.
The players with fully working ears were the ones who tuned out. The kids with no hearing at all were the ones locked in on every word. Hearing was never the variable that mattered. Attention was.
Most people aren't hard of hearing. They're hard of listening.
Build the Check, Not Just the Message
Fisher's cornerback wasn't a bad player. He was an unchecked one. Two working ears, and it didn't matter at all.
Hearing receives information. Listening creates action. If your captains keep saying "I got you" and then getting it wrong, that's not a discipline problem. It's a gap in how you're checking for understanding. Close it before the season gets to a moment where it costs you.
Raise the Game
Enroll now in our new course on confidence and connection, Why They're Not Listening: Coaching the Modern Athlete. If you’re ready to modernize your coaching, deepen your impact, and develop athletes who become leaders, not just performers, this course is your playbook.
Share this blog with a coach who needs it.
Drop me an email if this message hit home.
Your athletes are waiting for a coach who understands their language…
A coach who can connect, communicate, and elevate.
Let’s raise the game, together.