Here's a number worth sitting with: 140.
Researchers at UC Berkeley ran a study with MBA students (teams of eight or more people)and asked everyone one simple question: What percentage of the team's work did you personally contribute?
When they added up all the answers, the total wasn't 100 percent. It wasn't even close. Teams consistently claimed over 140 percent of the work.
Every single person believed they were doing more than their teammates realized. And here's the part that should make you stop — they weren't lying. The lead researcher said people were genuinely surprised by how much they over-claimed. They thought their reporting was accurate.
That's what makes this dangerous.
Because if every player on your team privately believes they're contributing more than they're getting credit for, you don't have a team problem. You have a math problem that turns into a people problem. And that people problem has a name.
Pat Riley called it The Disease of Me.
Success Is the Problem
Riley won five NBA championships as a head coach. He coached Magic, Kareem, Shaq, and D-Wade. He's one of the most successful coaches in the history of professional basketball. And in his book The Winner Within, he laid out something most coaches don't want to admit:
"The most difficult thing for players to do when they become part of a team is to sacrifice. It is much easier, and much more natural, to be selfish."
He's not saying players are bad people. He's saying selfishness is the default setting. And the Berkeley research backs him up, those MBA students weren't professional athletes trying to protect contracts. They were regular, intelligent people with no incentive to inflate their numbers. They just naturally did.
So what does that mean for your team? It means the Disease of Me isn't a character flaw. It's a human condition. And it gets activated not by failure, but by winning.
Riley called the pre-success phase The Innocent Climb. The team is hungry. Roles are clear. Sacrifice feels worth it because no one has arrived yet. Then the wins come, the recognition comes, and slowly, the math starts not adding up.
Riley identified what he called the 7 Danger Signals: the warning signs that the Disease of Me is already spreading through your locker room. Here's how to spot each one, and more importantly, what a captain can actually do about it.
Signal 1: Inexperience with Success
This is the first crack and it happens to good people. You get a big win, earn some recognition, and someone starts believing the hype before they've earned the right to believe it. We've arrived. I'm that guy.
Entitlement doesn't announce itself. It shows up in a slight drop in focus at practice, in someone coasting because the last game went well, in body language that says I've already done the hard part. They're not wrong that they contributed — they just don't realize that the standard goes up with success, not down.
What captains do: Make the debrief boring. After a big win, your job isn't to celebrate, it's to reset. Not "that was amazing," but "here's what we still need to fix." Find one thing. It doesn't need to be a crisis. It needs to signal that we haven't peaked. Because the team that stays hungry after a win is harder to beat than the team that thinks it already won.
Signal 2: Chronic Feelings of Under-Appreciation
Now the internal monologue starts: I'm not getting enough credit. I'm doing the work. No one notices.
This is precisely what the Berkeley study was describing, every player privately believes they're contributing more than the team realizes. When recognition doesn't match what they believe they deserve, that gap becomes resentment. Riley was clear: this signal has to be caught early, because left unaddressed, it festers.
What captains do: Build a recognition ritual and make it a system, not a gesture. Don't just call people out sometimes. Make it a daily habit — pregame, postgame, in the group chat. One teammate. One specific play. One sentence about why it mattered. Not "great job," but "that screen in the third quarter freed up the whole possession. That's why we scored." When recognition is consistent and specific, players stop chasing it because they know it's coming.
Signal 3: Paranoia About "My Share"
This is where it gets quiet and dangerous. Players start keeping score internally: minutes, stats, touches, roles. Am I getting what I deserve? Is someone else getting more than me?
Riley described this as a kind of consumption. When players get so locked into tracking their personal brand, team success becomes secondary. The tricky part? The player probably isn't saying any of this out loud. It's living in their head, shaping how they practice, creating invisible walls.
What captains do: Revisit the covenant. At the start of every season, great teams agree on something, what they're here to do, what sacrifice looks like, what the mission is. When someone starts score-keeping, you don't need a speech. Pull them aside. One question: "What did we agree to at the start of the year?" Not accusatory. Not a lecture. Just a reminder. The covenant does the heavy lifting so you don't have to.
Signal 4: Resentment of Teammates' Success
Now it shifts from me not getting enough to why is my teammate getting what I want? Riley called this one cancerous, one person quietly rooting for a teammate to fail can take a team from the top to the bottom faster than any opponent.
But here's what most coaches and captains miss: it rarely looks like hatred. It looks like silence. No reaction when a teammate scores. Hollow clapping. A half-second delay before the congratulations. That's the signal.
What captains do: Be first. Every single time. This is about speed, not sincerity. Everyone eventually feels happy for their teammate. Captains just do it first. First to clap. First to speak. First to post. When you're already moving toward a teammate before anyone else reacts, that behavior is visible. It gives everyone else permission to do the same. Culture is built in what gets celebrated, and you set the pace.
Signal 5: Personal Effort to Outshine a Teammate
This one is sneaky because it still looks like hustle. The effort is real. The intention is wrong.
I'm working hard so I stand out. So I get noticed. So I take his spot.
Riley distinguished between competition that lifts everyone and competition rooted in tearing someone else down. One fuels the team. The other slowly poisons it. And because the effort itself looks good on the surface, it can go unaddressed for a long time.
What captains do: Redirect the why. You don't want to kill the effort, you want to aim it. The question isn't "are you working hard?" It's "who benefits when you do that?" If the honest answer is "me," help them find the version of that same effort that makes the team harder to beat. Same energy. Different direction. Because great teams compete against a standard, not against each other.
Signal 6: Leadership Vacuum from Cliques and Rivalries
Now the team splits. Position groups. Friend groups. The guys who eat together. The guys who don't. Riley identified that when individuals feel disconnected from the group — when no one is actively pulling them in, they start building their own circle. Once those circles form, you don't have one team anymore. You have factions.
And cliques rarely start with the stars. They start with the guys on the edges, the peripheral players, the ones who feel invisible. No one reached for them, so they reached for each other.
What captains do: Own the middle by going to the edges. Not your boys. Not the starters. The guy eating alone. The freshman who hasn't found his footing. The one who isn't in the meme chain. Go find him. Sit with him. Ask him a real question. Pull him into the circle before he builds his own. You can't hold the middle if you're only spending time at the top.
Signal 7: Frustration Even When the Team is Winning
This is the final stage and the one that requires the most from a captain.
The team is winning. And someone is still unhappy. That's not a performance problem. That's ME over WE at its most exposed.
This is the moment where Riley's framework meets Road House. Yeah, Patrick Swayze. "Be nice… until it's time to not be nice." As a captain, you lead with patience. You give people the benefit of the doubt. But when a player's attitude is actively hurting the team while the team is winning, patience without action is just avoidance.
What captains do: Have the conversation no one else will. One on one. Not in front of the group. No speech. Just: "I need to talk to you about something because I think it's starting to affect us." Direct. Respectful. Specific. What separates a team captain from a team cheerleader is the willingness to say the hard thing to the right person at the right time.
The Truth About Culture
Here's what Riley understood that most teams don't: every team gets exposed to the Disease of Me. Every one.
The difference is what happens next. Some teams ignore it. They hope it passes. They protect relationships at the expense of standards. Great teams confront it early, directly, and consistently.
Riley put it simply: the best organizations make sacrifices, don't look for individual credit, cheer on their peers, speak with one voice, and make the bigger picture abundantly clear. That's not a motivational poster. That's a daily decision.
And it starts with you.
Because culture isn't what you say. It's what you allow.
The Captain Question
Where is the Disease of Me showing up on your team right now?
And the harder one: where is it showing up in you?
You cannot eliminate it in the room if you're tolerating it in yourself.
Weak leaders protect ego. Strong leaders protect the team. The Disease of Me is always there, waiting. But great captains don't ignore it. They don't avoid it. They step in, hold the standard, and choose every day, in small moments and big ones.
We over Me.
.webp)
Raise the Game
Enroll now in our new course on confidence and connection, Why They're Not Listening: Coaching the Modern Athlete. If you’re ready to modernize your coaching, deepen your impact, and develop athletes who become leaders—not just performers—this course is your playbook.
Share this blog with a coach who needs it.
Drop me an email if this message hit home.
Your athletes are waiting for a coach who understands their language…
A coach who can connect, communicate, and elevate.
Let’s raise the game—together.