Most coaches think they have a talent problem.
Most captains think they have a leadership problem.
Most of the time, they have a development problem.
Here's what that means: your team isn't broken. Your team is in a stage. And the stage they're in requires something specific from you, something that's completely different from what the next stage will require.
In 1965, psychologist Bruce Tuckman published a model of group development that has held up for sixty years because it describes something real. Groups don't become teams automatically. They move through predictable stages, whether coaches are aware of them or not. And the teams that build chemistry, accountability, and championship-level trust aren't the ones that skipped stages. They're the ones who were led well through each one.
The five stages: Forming, Storming, Norming, Performing, and Adjourning.
This is what they look like in a locker room, and exactly what coaches and captains should be doing differently in each one.
Phil Jackson Said It Best
Before we get into the stages, here's the frame:
"Good teams become great ones when the members trust each other enough to surrender the 'Me' for the 'We.'" — Phil Jackson
The entire Tuckman model is the story of how a group gets from Me to We. That journey doesn't happen automatically. It has to be coached. Here's how.
Stage 1: Forming — "The Hope Phase"
What It Looks Like
Think about Day 1 of fall camp. Everybody's excited. Everybody's optimistic. Nobody's been tested yet. The roster looks great on paper and the playoffs feel inevitable.
On the surface, everyone looks bought in. Players are polite, engaged, eager to make a good impression. But underneath that, they're all running the same internal calculus: Where do I fit? Am I good enough to start? Will these people accept me?
Conflict gets avoided because belonging feels more urgent than honesty. Nobody is rocking the boat because they're not sure yet if they're even on the boat.
What Coaches Need to Do
This is not the time for player-led everything. Your athletes need structure: standards, expectations, roles, culture. There's an old line worth keeping: unclear is unkind. Your job in Forming is to make everything crystal clear before behavior fills the vacuum and makes those decisions for you.
Set the mission. Define the norms. Establish roles. Do it early, because the team is watching everything right now, and they're forming beliefs about what this program is based on what they see in the first two weeks.
What Captains Need to Do
The trap for captains in this stage is thinking their job in week one is accountability. It's not. It's connection.
You don't earn the right to hold someone accountable until they feel like they belong. Sit with the new kid. Learn names. Include the freshman who doesn't know anyone. Create safety first. Standards come after.
People don't care about team expectations until they feel like they're part of the team.
Stage 2: Storming — "The Reality Phase"
What It Looks Like
The honeymoon ends. The first gut-punch loss happens. Conditioning gets real. Playing time becomes a live conversation. Someone loses a starting spot. Someone thinks the coach is wrong. Someone thinks the captain plays favorites.
And the conflict that everyone was suppressing in Forming? It surfaces.
This is Storming, and it's the stage where coaches panic, captains disappear, and teams either grow or fracture.
Why Storming Is Not Failure
Here's what most coaches get wrong: they treat Storming like a culture crisis. They try to eliminate conflict instead of teaching teams how to navigate it.
Storming is not failure. Storming is growth.
You cannot build trust without tension. You cannot build accountability without disagreement. You cannot become a team until you've survived something together that tested whether you actually were one. A team that avoids conflict will never reach its full potential. It will just stay comfortable and mediocre.
The key distinction: there's a difference between disagreement and disrespect. Athletes can tell the difference once you name it. Your job is to teach teams that disagreeing about tactics, roles, and standards is healthy, as long as it stays focused on the team and doesn't become personal.
What Coaches Need to Do
Don't panic. Don't interpret every argument as a character issue. Acknowledge the conflict and bring it into the room instead of managing it in hallways.
Get members to assume more task responsibility. This is the stage where shared leadership has to start emerging. If your captains are sitting back waiting for you to handle every conflict, that's a structure you need to address.
What Captains Need to Do
This is the stage where you find out if you're actually a leader or just someone with a title.
The move is from complaining to problem-solving. Anybody can identify what's wrong. Leaders help figure out what's next. That means asking: What's really going on here? What can we control? What do we need to do differently?
The "friend vs. leader" tension is never louder than it is in Storming. You cannot be everyone's friend and hold the standard at the same time. The team needs you to choose the standard.
The key shift that moves a team out of Storming: going from a testing and proving mentality to a problem-solving mentality. When the team stops asking "who's right" and starts asking "what do we need," that's the turn.
Stage 3: Norming — "The Buy-In Phase"
What It Looks Like
This is where things start to click. If you've done the work in Forming and survived Storming, you'll feel it before you can explain it.
Players accept their roles, not just the star's role but the whole depth chart. The backup midfielder understands why he matters. The second-string goalkeeper is genuinely supporting the starter. People stop asking what's best for me and start asking what's best for us.
Shared habits develop. Shared language. A shared identity. This is where culture stops being a poster on the wall and starts being how the team actually operates.
What Coaches Need to Do
Start stepping back. Let players solve problems. Ask more questions, give fewer answers.
A coach-led team can be good. A player-led team can be great.
The shift from directing to facilitating is a real skill, and most coaches don't practice it until they have to. Norming is when you have to. Allow shared leadership to emerge. Ask the team: "How do you propose we execute this?" And mean it.
What Captains Need to Do
Your job in Norming is to protect the norms. And that doesn't look like speeches or yelling. It looks like consistency. It sounds like: "Hey, that's not who we are." Simple. Calm. Repeated.
One warning: norms are happening whether you create them or not. Every team develops unwritten rules about how hard you practice, how you respond to mistakes, how you treat younger players. Captains decide what those rules are by what they reinforce and what they let slide.
A second warning: Norming has a trap. Teams get comfortable here. They start protecting the group vibe over growth. Cohesion and comfort are not the same thing. If you can't tell the difference, you'll mistake stagnation for culture.
Stage 4: Performing — "The Championship Phase"
What It Looks Like
Coaches who've had a team here know what it feels like, because it feels different from anything else.
Communication becomes automatic. Trust is high. Roles are clear. Players are anticipating each other before the play develops. They're not thinking. They're reacting. They're adapting. They're playing free.
Tuckman calls this interdependence, and that word matters. Not dependence on each other, not independence from each other. Interdependence. They can work individually, in small groups, or as a full unit, and the competency level doesn't drop. That's what a high-performing team actually looks like.
What Coaches Need to Do
Get out of the way. Trust the preparation. Focus on strategy, not motivation.
Your team doesn't need you to fire them up right now. They're already fired up. What they need is your trust.
What Captains Need to Do
The biggest mistake Performing teams make is thinking they've arrived. They stop doing the small things. And that's exactly when decline starts.
Performing isn't a destination. It's a daily choice.
One important caveat: Not every team reaches this stage. Not every season has enough time. But every decision you make in Forming, every conflict you navigate in Storming, every norm you reinforce or challenge — it's all building toward this or away from it.
The Stage Nobody Talks About: Teams Move Backward
Before we get to Stage 5, there's something Tuckman's model makes explicit that most coaches never fully internalize:
This isn't a straight line.
A Performing team can slide right back into Storming. It happens when a star player gets injured, a mid-season transfer arrives, an assistant coach leaves, or a losing streak starts. The trust that was built gets disrupted, and the team has to rebuild it.
That's not failure. That's a team development problem with a known solution: go back to what built the trust in the first place.
Coaches who understand this don't panic when their Performing team has a bad week. They diagnose the stage and respond to what the team actually needs, not what they need at peak performance.
Stage 5: Adjourning — "The Legacy Phase"
What It Looks Like
The final whistle blows. The season's over. The seniors clean out their lockers. And the team that spent six months building something real scatters.
Tuckman called this Adjourning. Some call it Mourning. Because even when the season was great, especially when the season was great, there's real loss in this stage. The routines are gone. The daily contact disappears. And people who never had to think about what this team meant to them suddenly feel the weight of it.
What Coaches Need to Do
This is not a logistics stage. It's an emotional one. Create real closure. Celebrate the journey, not just the record. Recognize contributions that never showed up in the box score. Tell the stories. Name the moments. People need to feel that what they built mattered.
What Captains Need to Do
Your job in this stage is about legacy. Leave the jersey better than you found it. Help the younger players carry the culture forward.
Because legacy isn't what you accomplished. It's what remains after you're gone.
The Coaching Application: Three Things to Walk Away With
1. Know what stage you're in, not where you want your team to be, but where they actually are.
What a Forming team needs and what a Storming team needs are completely different. Running Performing-level autonomy on a Storming team will lose them.
2. Your leadership style has to evolve with the team.
More directive early. More collaborative as trust builds. More hands-off as the team matures. This isn't being passive. It's being appropriate. The stage determines the style.
3. Develop your captains for every stage.
- Forming: Be visible. Create connection.
- Storming: Choose accountability over popularity.
- Norming: Facilitate and protect standards.
- Performing: Lead without waiting for permission.
- Adjourning: Close the loop. Pass the culture forward.
That's five different versions of the captain role across one season. Are you developing them for all five?
The Bottom Line
Stop judging your team by where you wish they were. Start leading them from where they actually are.
Every team forms. Every team storms. Every team norms. The best teams perform. And eventually, every team adjourns.
Your job as a coach or captain isn't to skip stages. It's to help your team move through them.
So here's the challenge: at your next practice, ask yourself one question. What stage are we actually in right now?
Because once you know where your team is in the journey, you know exactly what kind of leadership they need next.
That's the work. That's always been the work.
Raise the Game
Enroll now in our new course on confidence and connection, Why They're Not Listening: Coaching the Modern Athlete. If you’re ready to modernize your coaching, deepen your impact, and develop athletes who become leaders—not just performers—this course is your playbook.
Share this blog with a coach who needs it.
Drop me an email if this message hit home.
Your athletes are waiting for a coach who understands their language…
A coach who can connect, communicate, and elevate.
Let’s raise the game—together.